Wednesday, July 23, 2014

My First Stitch Fix!

I was super super excited to get my first Stitch Fix.  I had to wait THREE months to get it, and I was freaking out while I waited.  I tried not to buy anything new, as I had specifically asked for a maxi dress and a statement necklace, and I was holding out for those!

My Stitch Fix was delivered today. My curiosity got the better of me and I snuck a peek at the Stitch Fix site while I was at work and realized that I could see the names of the articles I had been sent, but not a photo.

I held my breath when I saw the words "geometric" and the word "chevron."  Hold up...there it is again..."chevron."  Chevron twice?  Really?

The Stitch Fix stylists are supposed to look at your Pinterest boards to get a feel for your personal style, so I tried to push the bad thoughts from my mind.  "They're professionals," I told myself.  "They know what they're doing."

And then I came home...to this:

If you know me at all, you'll notice right away that that specific color palette is NOT my style...not to mention, I don't really care for patterns.  But, okay.  This was put together by a stylist.  Who knows, maybe they know something I don't! Maybe it will look good on me!  So I pull everything out and, trying to stay optimistic, try it all on.

1. Pixley Laural Sleeveless Geometric Printed Maxi Dress

Gah, NOPE. I HAD asked for a maxi dress, and I already have one in black, so I was okay with a color (and pattern) except I was not a fan of this one.  It had a weird elastic waist that caused the back to ride up and wrinkle, the tiny geometric pattern called attention to EVERY imperfection, and the combination of high collar and thick straps made it just look frumpy.  Bigger girls like me need BIG patterns, not small ones, when it comes to maxi dresses. Bad move, Stitch Fix.  And they wanted $78 for this. I'm not above paying that much for a dress, but I'd have to really love it. Nope. Verdict? Sent back.

2. Pomelo Indiana Abstract Chevron Print Mixed-Material Tee


Don't mind the lines underneath this--I threw it on over a dress to see how it would look with a black skirt.  The answer? Bad.  The heather gray reminded me of a gym shirt, and the blue patterned sleeves were just busy and weird.  The worst part?  There was FOOD on the collar.  Gross, gross, gross. I guess that's the hazard that comes with getting previously-tried-on clothes. It WAS made of jersey cotton, which I love (well noted, stylist Cynthia!) but it wasn't enough to make me love the shirt as a whole. Verdict? Sent back!

3 & 4:

Kut from the Kloth Marquis Slub Knit Dolman Sweater 
Gilli Dawn Jersey Chevron Print Maxi Skirt

This COULD have been cute...but it wasn't.  The chevron skirt is just too busy (it makes me dizzy just to look at it! Maybe I should have mentioned to them that I have vertigo?) and the waistband was very strange--it really clung to my stomach and butt and was just not flattering.  Plus, the material was really hot.  I'm always hot as it is, so this wasn't going to fly.  Verdict? Sent back!

I considered keeping the top at first, but at $48 I didn't feel it was worth the price.  It looked too casual--like something you'd throw over a bathing suit while you're at the beach--and I knew I wouldn't wear it enough to justify that price.  If I wanted something like this, I could probably find it at Target for $15...plus, I hardly EVER wear white.  I'm okay with stepping out of my comfort zone, but this sweater isn't the piece of clothing that will get me to do that. Verdict? Sent back!

#5:
Gorjana Finn Open Teardrop Stud Earrings

It seems like they usually include one accessory in each Fix, and I was bummed to get these as mine. I was counting on a great statement necklace.  But, here's the thing: Stitch Fix charges you a $20 "styling" fee no matter what, BUT, if you buy something that they send you, you get to apply that $20 to that purchase.  Basically, if you don't use it, you lose it.
These earrings, at $40, were the cheapest item in the fix.  I'd have preferred something a little more fancy (maybe a chandelier earring) but they're okay. Verdict? Kept!

All in all, I was REALLY disappointed by my first Stitch Fix. You'd think they'd try to pull out all the stops to get you the greatest Fix so that you'd stick around, but nope. It seems that a lot of people have a terrible first Fix and they have to work with their stylist in order to improve them.  I wrote my stylist a LONG letter about what I'm looking for and what works for me, so hopefully my next Fix will be a lot better.  Like Birchbox and ipsy GlamBag, I'll give these guys three tries to get it right!  (And hopefully I won't wind up with three pairs of earrings that are "just okay.")

I'll be sure to blog about my next Fix!


If you like the sound of Stitch Fix and want to give it a try for yourself, please use my referral link!

No comments: